ZDoom

I remember how well the karma system was received on the skulltag forums.

Here's a hint: it didn't go down too well

I'm with Gez, Nash, Lud and Graf. I don't agree to the like button. The ZDoom Forums isn't a Facebook/Twitter place of gathering.. and it shouldn't be treated as such.

"Likes", karma/reputation systems and other such things never bring anything worthwhile to a forum IMO. They just result in people trying to game the system so as to have their existence validated by a meaningless statistic on a website. Cliques of people repping each other, like-bait posts, etc. We're much better off without this silliness.

ZDoom.org forum history lesson:

This place used to have a post counter under your avatar. It was swiftly removed by Randi after a lot of complaints... and to be honest, that was the best thing to have ever happened around here.

The end

That reminds me; wasn't there a photoshopped image showing the Projects forum with the "like" buttons next to each topic?

I don't think the suggestion was to link to Facebook, but rather to integrate a voting function to the site, like how reddit has upvotes, facebook has likes, etc, so users could agree with a post without commenting.

That said, I don't think it would be a good idea here. We already have enough of a problem with people posting just to be posting. Imagine if they were encouraged to post with shiny rank badges.

People do miracles for a bunch of likes. I've seen sex tapes get released for 10K likes in Facebook. I agree with Graf. Lets not turn this place into Facebook or any of the other social media.

Infesting the forum with links to data collecting sites like Facebook will get a strict 'no' from me. ZDoom.org is one of very few sites I run without a web filter, it'd be a shame if I had to add one here, too.

SkinlessSacks wrote:self explanatory, just a suggestion to like one's post.

What's stopping you from quoting said post and replying to it? A Likes counter is just a number.

self explanatory, just a suggestion to like one's post.