ZDoom

Finished it, it was very good... but I felt that the ending (though accurate for all Doom wads and the original games themselves) didn't necessarily have to be like that

Just finished it then.

The Good:
Fun to play, not too hard (even on hard difficulty), nice atmosphere on the later maps.

The Bad:
The last map had nowhere near enough ammo (on hard), most maps were too cramped, very random texturing (especially on the first 5 or so maps).

Overall though I liked it

I liked it. Good detail and good gameplay.

updated the wad.

fixed some errors on map46, almost everyone had problems there, and added a bit more ammo on map50 and fixed the ending door thing that i never fixed. :-)

hopefully thats all and no more. :-)

These maps look amazing in GZDoom with all the greens and reds.

Now all it needs is to satisfy my bizarre desire to see the Doom font in katakana. (or is that in there too? I've only played up to 45 so far...)