ZDoom Community Top Works of All Time

[Arcterezion]

5 - Psychic (Not perfect, but it's my favourite mod. Guns and magic with a currency and shop system is quite enjoyable to play.)
4 - Nashgore (Extra gore is fun, and this fits in with the graphics of Doom the best out of all of the gore mods that I've seen, and is extremely compatible.)
2 - Final Doomer (Loads of interesting weapons that aren't overpowered.)
2 - Combined_Arms (Also loads of interesting weapons, and without making levels too easy.)
1 - The Trailblazer (Not really into overpowered mods, but this is the exception.)
1 - Smooth Doom (Very pretty, but does not play nice with other mods.)

Honourable mention - Æons of Death (First Doom mod I've ever played. Had quite a bit of fun with it years ago.)

[m8f]

Arcterezion, thanks for voting!

The tally in the OP and labels have been updated.

[terminator44]

I've decided to update my votes so I will make a new post:
I am removing 1 point from CBlood and adding 1 point to Nashgore (since CBlood is just a companion mod to Nashgore).
I am removing 1 point from Project Brutality and adding 1 point to Supercharge.

All other votes are unchanged.

[m8f]

terminator44, thank you for updating your votes!

The tally in the OP and labels have been updated.

[CherubCorps]

So here is my vote

4 - Combined arms (Surprised that this isn't higher, needs a boost)
4 - Supercharge (Best vanilla mod, also needs a boost)
2 - Final Doomer (For the indecisive Doomer)
1 - La Tailor Girl (Kyoot!)
1 - Champions (Great mod)
1 - Colorful Hell (Best baddie mod)
1 - Angelic Waifus (My mod, just to get it on the board)
1 - Nashgore (Best gore mod)

Wish I had more points for more things.

[ZikShadow]

Would like to change some of my votes, if it's not too troubling.

1 - Blade of Agony | I still like ya for the grand effort, but everything recently has been frustrating, to say the least. The majority community that supports you haven't been the brightest peanuts in the shelf, too.
5 - Hideous Destructor | It keeps me thinking about it even when I'm not playing, it opened the gate to a world of wonderful subaddons never seen before in the Doom sphere, and the community for it has been way past cool. A mod truly unique.
0 - Guncaster | The more I think of it, the more I realize that even though I think it's cool, I haven't been playing this mod as much. Not of reasons of quality, goodness me no, it's just that it feels almost Russian Overkill like in that the moment I get the big guns, even tough maps became a breeze to beat. Challenge out of the window unless I arbitrarily increase it with overpowered enemy mods that can one shot me or pull up Nightmare.
0 - Trailblazer | Same for you, big shot. Nothing personal.
0 - Doom Incarnate | Wasn't big on all the anti-aliasing. Count the silly looking future Luger slide that's only halfway, too.

[m8f]

CherubCorps, thank you for voting!
ZikShadow, thank you for updating your votes!

The tally in the OP and labels have been updated. Also, labels were somewhat broken for some time, sorry for that.

[Xangelxal]

-La Tailor girl - 5 points (has a lot of variety and it's very fun)
-Angelic waifus - 3 points (challenging, but still fun)
-nash gore - 2 points (probably the best gore mod so far)
-Colorfull hell - 2 points (Fun and crazy to play)
-Embers of Armageddon (EOA) - 3 points (It's DOOM 2016 in doom 1993. What else can you ask?)

[m8f]

Xangelxal, thank you for voting!

Updated the OP and labels.

[terminator44]

I've decided to update my votes so I will make a new post:'

I am removing 1 point from DoomRL Arsenal and adding 1 point to Lt. Typhon: viewtopic.php?t=64378

All other votes are unchanged.

[m8f]

terminator44, thanks for updating your points!

Tally and labels updated.

[Guest]

Enhanced Vanilla Project: 5 viewtopic.php?f=43&t=58191
Hellrider: 5 viewtopic.php?f=43&t=68575
Ancient Aliens: 5

[m8f]

Minimal number of mods to vote for: 5. Not less.
Also, please log in, I need a name to assign points.

[ClessxAlghazanth]

-Walpurgis : 2 points (my favourite fantasy style mod , using fire/ice spells feels so good , compatibility with monster packs is a big plus)
-DRLA : 2 points (so much heart/work put into it , pure brilliancy , no 2 gameplays are the same)
-HXRTC Project Golden : 2 points (sheer amount of content , lots of easter eggs , shop system is fun to tingle with , Hud is so good it is used with other mods too)
-Doom Incarnate : 2 points Great Wolf3d style weapons mod , 2 characters with unique playstyle , weapons are satisfying to use. Goes well with monster mods like orthodox -Bratwurst and hellish stuff with Project Malice
-Project Re-Blood : 1 points (Best Blood conversion - sorry ZBloody Hell )
-Tekish's Simple Hud Addons: 1 points (Hitmarkers nad CrosshairHP are my defaults)
-Colorful Hell: 1 points (a default in my load order when using weapons only mods)
-Gearbox : 1 points (another default mod after discovering it , QoL stuff)
-SlomoBulletTime Ultimate : 1 points (enjoy Matrix/Max Payne gunfights in your Doom , compatible with everything I tried !)
-DN3Doom: 1 points (great DN3 mod , feels even better than the real thing )
-Metadoom:1 points (weapons and monsters from all Doom lore into 1 package !)

edited for correction and typo

[rayburn]

5 - Hedon
4 - Ascension
3 - Wrath of Cronos RPG
1 - Death Foretold (D4T)
1 - Heretical Doom
1 - Ashes 2063