ZDoom Community Top Mods of All Time (update 2018-12-11)

[m8f]

Tally and labels are updated.

[SunPraiser]

I guess mine would be:

5 - Quake Champions: Doom Edition
3 - Death Foretold (D4T)
3 - Beautiful Doom
2 - Winter's Fury
2 - La Tailor Girl

[Rebecca Hubbledock]

My votes:

- 5 Quake Champions: Doom Edition
- 5 Brutal Doom
- 5 Project Brutality
- 5 Russian Overkill
- 5 Lithium

[m8f]

My votes:

- 5 Quake Champions: Doom Edition
- 5 Brutal Doom
- 5 Project Brutality
- 5 Russian Overkill
- 5 Lithium

Under what name do you desire your votes to be added? Also, I probably should add a rule about having a ZDoom Forums account in order to vote in ZDoom Community Top Mods.

Also what phantombeta says below. The total points number cannot be greater than 15.

[phantombeta]

I'm pretty sure that's way more than 15 points. :P

[DoomKrakken]

5 for Guncaster
5 for Trailblazer
5 for QC:DE

Project MSX used to be pretty high on my radar, but I haven't played it in years now... even though I had finally modded it to fit my own personal tastes. Not to mention, the code was messy. Still the graphics, the sprites, and the gameplay are fairly top-tier. As of right now, though, it's pretty much still in the past.

I would've also voted for D4T... since the sprites there are amazing, as well as some of the gameplay. However, uber randomization sucks, considering DOOM was all about consistency... as well as the immeasurably numerous liberties taken. This is unfortunately a trait that most (if not all) DOOM to Doom mods suffer from... at least for me.

[m8f]

Please vote for at least 5 mods.

[m8f]

The tally has been updated.

Rebecca Hubbledock: please state your name to be listed, and assign the points so it is 15 points total.
DoomKrakken: please vote for at least 5 mods.

[The_Abysswalker]

5 - Quake Champions: Doom Edition
3 - Death Foretold (D4T)
3 - Ashes 2063 TC
2 - ZBlood+
2 - AEons Of Death

[m8f]

The tally in the OP and labels have been updated.

[lizardcommando]

I'll throw in my own mod, Lizard Squad, along with Smooth Doom, Weapons of Saturn, Neutronion Chaos, Massmouth 2 and Action Doom 2.

[Captain J]

I appreciate your vote and towards my mod, Net-ronian Chaos! But please consider reading the voting rules on the 1st page First!;

The rules:

1. Minimal number of mods to vote for: 5. No less.
2. Maximal number of mods to vote for: 15. No more.
3. Maximal number of points that one mod can receive: 5. No more.
4. Maximal number of total points: 15. No more.
5. Self-voting is allowed only if the voted work is not present in the list, and no more than 1 point per work.

---

5 - favorite mod
4 - 2nd favorite
3 - 3rd favorite
2 - 4th favorite
1 - 5th favorite

or:
3 - a favorite mod
3 - a favorite mod
3 - a favorite mod
3 - a favorite mod
3 - a favorite mod

or:
1 - mod 1
1 - mod 2
1 - mod 3
1 - mod 4
1 - mod 5
1 - mod 6
1 - mod 7
1 - mod 8
1 - mod 9
1 - mod 10
1 - mod 11
1 - mod 12
1 - mod 13
1 - mod 14
1 - mod 15

Please state clearly how many points you give to each mod.
You can change your votes in the future (please, make a new post instead of editing an old one).

[lizardcommando]

Lizard Squad: 1
Smooth Doom: 1
Weapons of Saturn: 1
Netronion Chaos: 1
Massmouth 2: 1

[m8f]

lizardcommando: Thanks for voting! Remember, you still have 10 unassigned points. You can assign them at any time you want. If you do, please make a new post.

The tally in the OP and labels have been updated.

everyone: Congratulations! We've reached 200 mods in the list! I hope the list will go on and on.

Still, there are new heights to reach. For example, Doomworld Community Top is ahead of ZDoom Community Top by 2 voters. I don't want to turn this into competition, but...

[eharper256]

If this is still open:

3 - Shades of Doom
3 - Argent
3 - La Tailor Girl
3 - Heretical
3 - Doom RL Arsenal

I'd like to alter my votes, if that's okay, to the following:
2- Shades of Doom [-1]
2- Argent [-1]
2- La Tailor Girl [-1]
2- Heretical [-1]
2- Weapons of Saturn [+2]
1- Bulleteye [+1]
1- Brutal Doom: Tomtefar's Expansion [+1]
1- Champions [+1]
1- Doom RL Arsenal [-2]

Man, I wish I could have a new set of votes entirely, as I feel bad dropping points from things, and there are others I'd love to mention as well, but alas, woe.