ZDoom

Finally got fixed. Sorry it took over a year...

Not surprising because I haven't touched that code.

I gave this another try in 0.8.1 and it still doesn't work.

Thanks for that piece of info. I'll fix it ASAP.

Oh, that's it? Thanks.

music { id "intro" file "dukedc/music/tbss.ogg" }

music { id "intro" file "./dukedc/music/tbss.ogg" }

The reason the music doesn't load is because Raze does not interpret the following as a relative path:
[code]music { id "intro" file "dukedc/music/tbss.ogg" }[/code]

and the fix really is as simple as changing it to the following:
[code]music { id "intro" file "./dukedc/music/tbss.ogg" }[/code]

Otherwise the file structure works fine.

[quote="markanini"]I can confim, in 0.5.1 the new music isn't loaded, and midi device selection and cd music toggle still operate when they should be overriden. I checked with printfs comand to confirm the file was loaded, I suspect the definition file isn't being interpreted.[/quote]
I've also checked this and honestly I think NBlood's approach is the flawed one in this particular case with CD music in Blood: https://www.doomworld.com/forum/topic/111839-source-port-introducing-raze-thats-one-duked-up-space-marine/?page=8&tab=comments#comment-2096172

[quote]
Actually, if anything, I think NBlood is the one doing it wrong. I just took a look at the .def file's code and nothing inside it points to such behavior, so unless proven otherwise, I think Raze is right in its approach. The fact that the [b][i]sound toggle[/i][/b] itself also becomes unusable with the package loaded further highlights this, that should definitely not be happening (ye, I just tested it myself in NBlood too).

This is the code inside the .def file:
[code]
music { id "CBLOOD1" file "music/CBLOOD1.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD2" file "music/CBLOOD2.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD3" file "music/CBLOOD3.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD4" file "music/CBLOOD4.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD5" file "music/CBLOOD5.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD6" file "music/CBLOOD6.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD7" file "music/CBLOOD7.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD8" file "music/CBLOOD8.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD9" file "music/CBLOOD9.ogg" }
music { id "CBLOOD10" file "music/CBLOOD10.ogg" }
music { id "UNHOLY" file "music/UNHOLY.ogg" }
music { id "PESTIS" file "music/PESTIS.ogg" }
[/code]
It's just simple paths to the music, nothing that takes the control away from the user in an abusive way.
[/quote]

I can confim, in 0.5.1 the new music isn't loaded, and midi device selection and cd music toggle still operate when they should be overriden. I checked with printfs comand to confirm the file was loaded, I suspect the definition file isn't being interpreted.

I'm taking this as confirmation it's a bug and not PEBCAC.

Ok, that most likely means that the data is not written to the proper place.

Nothing useful.

I get the usual complaints about "else with no if" in ORGANTIC and pigshootenemystate from the standard CON files, then (if using the original zip) two warnings about failing including duke3D_hrp.def on duke3D.def:3 and :4 and then nothing. I set "developer" to 1 but it doesn't produce more messages.

Any info in the console?

Fails means that the menu screen plays GRABBAG instead of TBSS, and when I start the first map of the extension (third episode, replacing Shrapnel City) and hear INHIDING.MID instead of LIBERTY.

I even tried editing the duke3d.def file from dukedc_music20.zip to comment out the parts where it includes HRP stuff, because it caused error messages in Raze's console. Also to make it load the MIDI instead of the OGG. To no avail.

The graphic replacement does work, though. I do get 2456_dc.bmp to display. Not sure about the sound replacements. The soundtrack definition doesn't work.

What does "fails" mean? How far do you get?

raze.exe /gdukedc.grp /gdukedc_music.zip

I'm talking about [url=http://jamespaddockmusic.com/2017/04/30/duke-it-out-in-d-c-midi-pack-released/]this unofficial add-on[/url]. I'm not managing to get it to work.

First attempt, just drag-and-dropping the zip. Fails. Too bad.
Second attempt, extracting the content, making a bat file as suggested, except with raze instead of eduke32:
[code]raze.exe /gdukedc.grp /gdukedc_music.zip[/code]
Fails also.

Extract zip content, drag-and-drop extracted directory. Still fails.

At this point I'm thinking of directly editing dukedc.grp, but 1) I have zero experience of Build editing and 2) AFAIK data files are identified by their checksums so any modification would make it no longer be recognized.