What did I do? The first two frames are using the heavily damaged/hurt frames instead of the roughly 50% face that the original sprites used. Since the only real way Doom Guy can gib is if he is in the lower health ranges. Here are the two sprites below. Also, for those who needs a comparison:
Spoiler: COMPARE!Edit: I know about the first frame lacking the jaw starting to come through his face, without it though - it seems more.. Extreme Death'd.